anytime plumbing
01 Sep

A Comparison of Gas vs. Electric Water Heaters

If you’ve had your water heater longer than 10 years and repairs are becoming more frequent, it may be time to consider replacing it before it quits working altogether.  Enter the comparison of gas vs. electric water heaters.  While both types produce similar results, there are some differences that Anytime Plumbing wants you to be aware of where energy efficiency and options are concerned.

Before you start shopping for that new appliance, you need to weigh out the differences when comparing its power source.  Remember, this is the water heater that is going to keep your water hot for the next 10 years.  We understand that your budget may not allow you to purchase the most expensive model out there.  But then again, paying the highest dollar doesn’t guarantee quality when comparing gas vs. electric water heaters. Thus, you can always look for recommendations by calling in the experts and get their opinion on your specific needs. 

What should you consider first?

When purchasing a new water heater, you want to choose a model that will provide a sufficient amount of hot water for the entire household yet be energy-efficient and save you money on your monthly utility bill.  Look at the different types that are currently available in order to determine the right fuel source and size for your home.  The Federal Government has posted plenty of information the energy efficiency of different appliances including gas vs. electric water heaters.

How many different types of water heaters are there?

It’s always a good idea to be aware of the different types of gas and electric water heaters that are currently available on the market today.  This should also help with the decision-making process.  Keep in mind that heating water is the second biggest expense in your home and accounts for 14% to 18% of your monthly utility bill.  So, picking the right water heater is not just about comfort, it’s about energy efficiency as well.  There are 5 types that all of the Anytime Plumbing experts are familiar with:

Condensing water heater – if natural gas is the primary energy source that your home uses, this type of water heater may be your best option.  This version heats water by funneling the heated exhaust of a natural gas system.

Conventional storage tank water heater – this is the type that most of us are used to.  It features a tank of water that gets heated for use in your bathrooms and kitchen and determines the amount of hot water that is available for use.

Heat pump or hybrid water heater – since it doesn’t generate heat directly, this water heater can save money on your electricity bill.  In order to heat the water, the heat pump or hybrid water heater moves the heat from the air or the ground to the water.

Solar powered water heater – when it comes to comparing gas vs. electric water heaters, this is probably the most energy-efficient water heater of the bunch.  This water heater gets its energy from roof-mounted solar panels that generate energy and convert it into electricity.

Tankless water heater – this type is often referred to as an “on-demand” water heater because it can heat water almost immediately in super-heated coils instead of in a tank.  Because of its ability to heat water so quickly, tankless water heaters are available in different sizes and are ideal for larger families.

So how does gas vs. electric water heaters compare where purchase and utility bills cost are concerned?

For the purpose of keeping our customers and visitors better informed, Anytime Plumbing is basing these comparisons on previously installed 40-gallon water heaters.  Here is a breakdown of the cost differences between purchase, installation, and operating costs of gas and electric water heaters:

Gas water heaters:

  • Average cost – $1,300 to $2,600
  • Available in a range of sizes
  • Can be used during a power outage
  • Heats water quicker
  • Higher upfront cost, lower monthly energy costs
  • Requires more maintenance
  • Some safety concerns

Electric water heaters:

  • Average cost – $950 to $1,500
  • Available in a range of sizes
  • Cannot be used during a power outage
  • Doesn’t heat water as quickly
  • Lower upfront cost, higher monthly energy costs
  • Less maintenance required
  • No safety concerns

Thus, as you can clearly see when comparing gas vs. electric water heaters, both have their advantages and disadvantages. Ultimately, the decision rests on your shoulders. If you have queries or need more information about it, you can always call us. Our team of experts are available to help you choose the best for your home. For more information about gas and electric water heaters, contact Anytime Plumbing at your earliest convenience.

Contact Us

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Get a no obligation, consultation by giving us a call today. Or fill out our form and we'll get back to you in email.

Amer Zaghlouleh is the owner of Anytime Plumbing Inc., a trusted plumbing company serving Santa Cruz County. With a focus on delivering quality work and reliable service, Amer has established himself as a respected professional in the industry. He believes in providing honest and trustworthy plumbing solutions to every customer, ensuring their satisfaction and peace of mind. With years of experience and a commitment to staying updated with the latest technical advances, Amer and his team at Anytime Plumbing Inc. are fully equipped to handle any plumbing job with precision and efficiency. Trust in Amer's expertise and dedication for all your plumbing needs.